Frequently
Asked Questions 2007
Frequently
Ask-The-Doctor Questions Asked
Archives
2006
2005
Q &
A
Posted November 12, 2007
Q
I have a question, or a dilemma actually. I suffered a high ankle
sprain. It didn't really hurt much and I had no idea what a high ankle
sprain was at the time. For two days it was painful, but no swelling
really at all, and therefore I didn't think it was anything serious or
worth going to a doctor for. So 6 weeks passed by, and then it started
bothering me out of nowhere, so went to a doctor finally.
He took x-rays and diagnosed me with a high ankle sprain, and my
pressure x-rays showed a mortis space. However, he told me that since it
had been 6 weeks already, that surgery wouldn't really help because scar
tissue had formed in the space. So he put me on crutches and a boot for
5 weeks. After this immobilization period I went back and the space had
not widened and he told me I can start physical therapy and should be ok
over time.
But I am concerned because my ankle still hurts. Its not very painful
but it is sore and very sensitive to touch around the ligaments. I'm
just wondering...do you think the advice Ive been receiving is good. It
seems to me from what I've read and heard, that I should have had a
surgery to bring the space closed. But he assured me it wasn't worth it
at this point (large surgery, tough for success). So do you think I
should be ok ??
I am very active and want to be able to run again and everything? I'm
worried about long term problems of improper treatment. Is this soreness
I have normal?? It has now been 11 weeks since time of injury, but I
waited the 6 weeks before seeing the doctor and being immobilized.
I would appreciate it so much if you could give me a brief opinion.
A
The
clinical picture is best when one has the opportunity to examine the
injury. First, based on your description, the physician did choose
appropriately, although, I am not an orthopedic surgeon to make that a
expert medical opinion. Even though you have a high ankle sprain, other
structures do get sprained, such as the small but vunerable ligaments
that connect the smaller bones to the large tibia and fibula.
Although
treatment was proper, you may need physical therapy to assess the
ligaments and range of motion of your ankle. At my clinic we manipulate
osteopathically the ankle bones into best alignment and that reduces the
strain and secondary inflammation. If you are in the southwest Florida
area, you are welcome to stop by and I could evaluate it for you.
Posted November 12, 2007
Q
If a trapezius muscle is damaged from injury
if it can cause injury to the scaleane muscle group?
A
Yes,
frequently the scalenes are involved are the are closely linked with the
scalene muscle group, especially in a neck whiplash injury. There is a
simple screening test for the scalene muscle involvement. Extend your
arm forward as if you were a policeman signaling someone to stop. Then
"fold" your finger tips closed tightly with your hand in the open "stop"
position. The distal finger tips should close tight. If you have a
slight gap between your distal finger tips and your middle finger area,
you may have a strain of your scalene muscle group. Hope this helps.
Posted November 12, 2007
Q
I saw your name in conjunction with a Softball Pitching Injury
Report via the internet and was wondering if you could help me.
In early 2000 I viewed a medical report, shown to me by the great HERB
DUDLEY, regarding Softball pitching and NERVE DAMAGE to the thigh area.
This occurs as pitchers slap their leg with the glove in the back swing
and/or at the release of the pitch. Originally this glove movement was
taught to fall back behind the stride leg. But somehow, this movement
has transformed to the slapping motion. And used by a great percentage
of pitchers.
I remember nothing about the report except that HERB was adamantly
against this motion and dismissed his students that used it. I warn my
students about possible injury but have wondered, is this a real
concern? I have not read or heard any more about it since. If this is a
concern, I believe the Pitching World should know about it.
Herb passed away in the past year so I have no way to see that report
again. Have you know anything regarding this injury or could you direct
me to someone who might? I would appreciate your response.
A
The
concern is valid. By slapping your thigh you can damage a superficial
nerve in the thigh called the lateral femoral cutaneous nerve. I would
look up this nerve anatomy and see if it corresponds to his
description. Let's start here and write back if you have further
questions.
Posted November 12, 2007
Q
I fractured my wrist 3 weeks ago breaking
boards in Tae Kwon Do class. It is a non-displaced distal ulna - its
right at the wrist joint - it caught the edge of the board. What is
the normal healing time for this in a splint and will there be any long
term complications from this?
The doctor would not really give me
any straight answers - it may heal or it may not but you may not even
experience any problems. He also gave me the option of a full arm cast or
a splint 3 weeks ago and said the cast was the best option for healing but
no guarantees and I would probably heal just fine with the splint with no
problems. I'm 40 years old, in good health and never had a fracture in my
life.
Can you give me some straight
answers and treatment recommendations to help heal quickly as I want to
get back to Karate class as soon as possible and at 100%.
A
The healing
occurs at three weeks for "normal" use, but six weeks before you can do
strenuous activity. A non displaced spiral fracture is the best case
scenario for a fracture as it will heal nicely. If you looked through my
web page, there is a good article about
wrist injury that concerned my son.
You may have a similar result, the
fracture site healed 100% but he lost movement of his wrist and
experienced pain with movement and resistive force. In addition to a
fracture, your carpal or wrist bones may shift causing friction and
malalignment problems with persistent swelling and pain. Hope this helps.
Posted November 7, 2007
Q
My son was involved in a car
accident 11 months ago which resulted in an 80% compression spinal
fracture. He had surgery on L-4 and L-5, two 9 inch rods, two crossbars
and 9 screws put in. He has gone through 11 months of therapy. The
injury effected his bowel, bladder and reproductive functions. He has
regained bowel and bladder use completely.
The range of motion in his right
ankle area is very limited. He has limited feeling in his toes. Therapy
is soon ending except for what he is to do at home on his own. His
balance has been effected and he isn't able to walk as a normal 25 year
old should. He walks very slow due to the balance issue.
The surgeon shared with us post surgery, what he has back at 9-12 months
is what he will get back.
My
question is how long does it take nerves to heal from the area of his
spine to his ankle? He is 6 foot 2 inches. Is there a chance that he may
not regain total recovery to the nerves to his ankle? Someone said
nerves heal at a rate of a half of inch every month.
Thanks for assisting me in helping to try to understand and be
supportive to him.
A
Thanks for your inquiry, and I
apologize for the delay in responding to you. Sorry about your son's
injury. The spinal nerves do get damaged and do recover at the rate that
you were told. My question is whether the nerve damage is at the level of
the spin or lower in the leg or ankle. A neurologist can study nerves and
their recovery patterns with a test called a nerve conduction velocity
test and the muscles the nerve innervates with an EMG which are usually
done together. The balance issue may be of multiple causes such as head
trauma, hip-pelvic fractures, and a neurologist can help determine the
cause of his balance problem. I know I wasn't as helpful as you may have
wanted me to respond, but your son's case is a bit more complex for me to
speculate of the origins of his deficits. Hope this is a start.
Posted October 11, 2007
Q
I have a quick question for you and I hope
that you can help me out. I suffered a type 1 radial head fracture
about a year and a half ago. I went through all the therapy and it has
healed, however I am still not able to fully extend my arm. I am losing
about 20 degrees from full extension.
Its a little painful, especially when I try to
extend it and sometimes when I bend my elbow I can feel a popping
sound. I haven't seen a doctor, but I plan to in the near future. I
know from what I read that loss of motion is common with radial head
fractures. I was wondering if surgery was possible to restore my full
range of motion. I am a male and 40 years old. Any help you can
give me would be appreciated.
A
Thank you
for your inquiry. First of all, I am not an orthopedic surgeon and
cannot give you an opinion on any surgical correction. However, I think
that you should have further diagnostic tests performed and reviewed by
a competent orthopedic surgeon in your area. The concern lies in the
positioning of the head of the radius in conjunction with proper joint
alignment.
If the
head is displaced, alignment through surgery may be necessary to obtain
maximal range of motion. If you choose not to identify all your
options, the available options of surgical correction may diminish the
chances of success in restoring functional and optimal range of motion.
An MRI may be the more definitive diagnostic test, but I would defer to
the orthopedist that will assume your care.
Posted September 25, 2007
Q
Is there a isolated cervical stretch i can do
x-rays say disk disease C6-7 chiropractor adjustments no help medical
doctor no help physical therapy no help. I am tired of fooling
with these people just want relief from stiffness from neck and
shoulders. I am 48 year old male and an avid walker doctor says to
keep walking but this doesn't help either.
A
Isolated
stretches that you can do for your self are Active Isolated Stretching
developed by Aaron Mattes who has authored a book with illustrations for
self stretching which can be effective. His web site is
www.stretchingusa.com
Posted September 17, 2007
Q
Can the C2 make you have bad headaches?
I have a bone spur at my C2. What can I do about it? The
pain is so hard to bare at times.
A
Your problem at C2 usually will
cause headaches. The reason for the headaches are the many neuro
sensors of ligaments, small muscles, and the attachment of supporting
tendons that allow our skull to flex forward and backwards, along with
rotating it to the right and left that have nerve sensors that refer
pain into the back of the skull and result in headaches. Occasionally a
chiropractor versed in C2 alignment may help or a neurologist may offer
a nerve block of the occipital nerve that travels in this area in the
back of the skull. Hope this helps.
Posted September 17, 2007
Q
Bike accident. Landed on right
side. Painful ribs but x-ray does not show breakage. However, still
severe pain after 4 days. Pain killers help a lot. Could it be
liver damage because i get pain after heavy meal but I do have normal
bowel functions.
A
Falling down on the right side
could easily injure the liver. You may want to ask for a CT scan of the
abdomen to assess the liver. Blood work including liver enzymes may
show injury to the liver as well. Bring this to the attention of your
physician.
Posted September 17, 2007
Q
I had an L5 fusion 12-05, 1-06 a second
operation to take out the pin out of my vertebrae, this didn't help,
12-06 third operation things were much better, now I beginning to get
all the leg pain back, back pain, sometimes the back feels like a
broken mirror, the worse pain was yesterday a "tuck and roll" to get
out of bed.
Over the past 3 months as my systems from my
back worsen, I began to get large multiple bruises on my thighs. They
send me for blood test all comes out negative. Today Today Today
I have 5-6 large bruises 1 1/2" to 3" in length. The bruising stopped
for 2 weeks but came back when my back started. I do have some nerve
damage that's apparent, like I can't feel the top of my foot.
Are these symptoms related?
A
Thanks for you inquiry. I am
writing quickly as I prepare to make hospital rounds, but felt compelled
to answer you. The bruises you describe are the disturbing part of this
clinical presentation. Bruising occurs from trauma, force to the skin
and tissues or a problem with normal blood clotting. Normal blood
clotting can be impaired by liver inflammation or medicines that
interfere with clotting factors.
Liver inflammation can be caused
by excessive Tylenol usage, narcotic usage, as narcotics have a high
dose of Tylenol within them. Alcohol can contribute to the problem or
even Hepatitis A, B, or C and change the liver's ability to maintain
normal clotting ability. Aspirin products can cause bruising or if you
take blood thinners such as Coumading or Plavix. You should consult
with your primary physician sooner than later. Secondly, I don't know
of any direct correlation of bruising with the nerve damage or surgery.
Let me know what they find
Posted September 16, 2007
Q
A lot of athletics are
complaining about their arms hurting after being taught in school to
throw weighted balls. Is it appropriate to have this kind of training
in order to be a pitcher in baseball? It is taking some several weeks
to recover. I will appreciate your answer.
A
Thank you for your question
and it is a good question. In my education and training, I would have
responded that throwing weighted balls that cause symptoms of pain
should be discontinued. However. I have observed the training of a
former Cy Young pitcher, Mike Marshall who also holds a degree in
Kinesiology from Michigan State University who bases his training
program on large weighted oversized balls. Additionally, he has a novel
new unorthodox style of training that has not resulted in any worsening
of injury as he has helped a few professional players rehabilitate via
his program. In any case, he is readily accessible to communicate by
phone or his web site
www.drmikemarshall.com
I would defer to his experience and training to address your question.
Posted August 9, 2007
Q
I was recently in a car accident. During the
last couple of days I have had several new symptoms with my legs; not
being able to walk without pain, shaking legs, weakness, etc. I went to
visit my Dr. today and he diagnosed me with Arthero... Clauditis or
something like that. In an effort to find out more about it, I came on
line tonight to find out more. I cannot find anything about this. My
Dr. referred me to an Oncologist and also a vascular surgeon to rule out
things that would be causing this pain. I have been taken out of work
now for the next couple of weeks because of my inability to walk, etc.
Please write back if you know what this is or could provide more
information on this. I may have spelled it wrong, etc. but basically,
muscle pain, soreness coupled by not being able to walk long distances
without being tired, etc.
A
Some
clinical information is missing for me such as your age and other
medical health problems that you may have had prior to the accident.
The reason I reflect on this is my concern on why you are referred to an
oncologist a cancer specialist and vascular specialist.
Trauma of any kind to the spine
with consequences of leg weakness should be investigated with an MRI of
the low back, the lumbar spine. If nerve damage is suspected on the
physicians examination, a nerve test should be ordered in the form of an
EMG-NCS. This is a test of the nerves and muscles that these nerves
control. Bruising of the nerve or pinching on the nerves can result in
muscle weakness, numbness and pain.
The symptoms of fatigue of
muscles with prolonged walking is more classic of claudication or
obstructive blood vessel disease from risk factors of diabetes, smoking,
and high lipids as the most common. Other medical conditions can also
contribute to the narrowing of these large blood vessels that supply the
blood to the muscles.
Based on what information you
have presented, an MRI of the lumbar spine is the most important test to
establish the cause or diagnosis of your problem. This test will find
or eliminate the most serious and most urgent medical conditions. After
this test, a consultation with a neurologist may be warranted if the
problem is suspected to be of a nerve injury.
I hope this helps you chart your
medical planning. If I can help further, please write back.
Posted August 9, 2007
Q
I am experiencing
significant swelling of the lateral aspect of the left knee, especially
when the leg is bent to 90 degrees or greater. During extension
swelling is visible on both the medial and lateral sides (lateral
worse). The knee is very tight and is weak especially when during
movements such as rising from a sitting position, the act of sitting
down and going up and down stairs. Is this something I should have
examined soon?
47 y/o WF. Hx of
Osgood Schlatter’s, osteoarthritis. Surgery for medial meniscus tear and
lateral retinacular release about 20 years ago on right knee. This is the
first time I’ve had any symptoms from the left knee at all.
A
You may have had similar
symptoms on your right knee. Swelling inside the knee joint suggests
some type in internal derangement, and with your symptoms, a meniscal
(cartilage) problem is high on the list. I would suggest an evaluation
by an orthopedic surgeon who specializes in knee operations, and an MRI
of the knee may be the best diagnostic test to identify the problem.
Hope this helps.
Posted August 9, 2007
Q
I am a chiropractor who now
teaches with the athletic injury dept. at a nearby chiropractic
college. I have a question re: the supraspinatus muscle.
Warfel's "The Extremities" states
that the supraspinatus muscle's action is to Abduct the arm; fixes the
humeral head in the glenoid; and rotates the humeral head laterally. It
then sites Gray's anatomy as a reference.
I have found no other literature to
support the aspect of the supraspinatus muscle rotating the humeral head
laterally. Do you know of any EMG studies that support this data?
A
The best individual to ask is
Dr. Basmajian in Canada. He is retired, but lives near Hamilton,
Ontario and is the pioneer of this type of research. I personally don't
have objective nor conclusive studies to demonstrate this movement.
However, as the supraspinatus does insert laterally into the proximal
humeral head ever so slightly off center, it most likely has some
rotational torque. Rotation should be reported as more inward or
outward, inversion--eversion, but it is difficult to comprehend a
"lateral rotation: therefore I share your confusion. Sorry I couldn't
be of more help.
Posted August 9, 2007
Q
I am currently studying
sports science and was wondering if you would help me with a query I
have I was wondering what joint and joint actions are used during a golf
swing.
A
Biomechanical Engineers and
Kinesiologists are best source to answer your question. If there is one
or two specific questions you may have, I will try to answer them and
please write me back.
Posted August 9, 2007
Q
I am very excited to have come
across your web page. I read with excitement the article on Joint
Mobilization of the Wrist.
I am a 35 year old female. I work
in an office on a computer most of my day. I normally work 30 hours a
week but have been on a 12 hour work week since the end of June to get
some of issues fixed.
On January 07 I had a severe radius
displacement in my left wrist due to a snowboarding accident. A plate
and screws were put in and a carpal tunnel release done as well. Several
of the hand bones were misaligned and a small hand bone above the ulna
was also broke. The surgeon said that it should heal just fine without
anything else needed. According to the x-ray it has and looks to be in
the right location. After several months of physical therapy I still am
unable to rotate the left wrist.
I met with the surgeon yesterday.
He doesn't know what the problem is. He can't do an MRI because of the
plate and at first wanted to do an exploratory surgery but now he just
wants to take that broken bone out to fix the problem. In addition to
that problem, I had a nerve conduction test which showed that I now also
have a pinched nerve in my left elbow but no one has told me with nerve
it is.
I have been in physical therapy
for that for the last month as well as calaflam anti-inflamatory and
don't experience any lasting relief. I am applying ice once - twice a
day but that is about it other than taking the anti-inflamatory. The
surgeon said I am suffering from tennis elbow.
On top of that in my right wrist I
have a cyst which is causing incredible amounts of discomfort, mild
carpal tunnel and the surgeon says that I have tennis elbow in my right
elbow as well.
So my question is which one do I
fix first? I am so frustrated by all the pain and discomfort. If I fix
my right wrist first which is probably some of the worst pain then I am
worried about making my left elbow worse which is a very close 2nd to my
worst pain. The right wrist and left elbow switch back and forth to
which is the worse. Or do I try and fix the left so that when the cyst
is removed in my right my left won't be so bothersome. Do I get a 2nd
opinion? Do I go to the chiropractor and see if he can try your joint
mobilization directions to get me relief? My right elbow is certainly
working on catching up with my left elbow and right wrist in the pain
dept so I know I need to do something but I am just lost as to what.
A
You have had a fall with both
arms and wrists, but the fracture occurred on the right wrist. However,
the right wrist problem is independent of the left elbow. The joints of
our body do shift ever so slightly, and when they do, the muscles strain
from this shift.
Tennis elbow results usually from
a slight shift of the wrist (carpal) or elbow connection of the ulnar or
radial bones. As your wrist situation is too complex to comment on with
any degree of certainty, I will comment on your elbows. A chiropractor is
a viable option to consult with to help provide a mobilization technique
to "re-align" the elbow joint and release the pressure of the muscle and
possibly the ulnar nerve that may be irritated.
Posted August 8, 2007
Q
In advance, thank you for
reviewing my question.
I was at my pain clinic for a 90
day check up, and I was c/o pain in my neck, and feeling like I
have sleeping in my right hand and arm. I have RSD bilaterally in my
lets and feet.
I fell while I was shopping with
my family, stepping down from a curve to the parking lot and hid my
spine/neck area on a "handicap sign post"... it hurt!.. with help from
my husband and two gentleman who were there at the store, I was able to
get up.
Since then, I have pain and h/a
at the base of my neck, and have numbness in my fingers, arm and
shoulder. The clinic MD who was mostly interested in my progress with my
RSD, just seem to "look over" my injury. I fell about a month ago, and
the MD I saw at the pain clinic, said, well, it could be a c-6 strain.
I have strength in at area, but
the pain and liminitation is remarkable. He said we would look at it
again in Oct when I was there again. But it continue to bother me,
it's the headache, and the hand problems that worry me. Am I feeling
just too worrisome?
A
Your state of health is complex
with a diagnosis of RSD of your lower extremities. The neck muscles as
well as the nerves from the cervical (neck) spine can refer pain down
the distribution of the arm and hand.
The nerves and the muscles
have their own specific pattern of numbness which helps the clinician
diagnose the problem more specifically. As you describe a newer injury to
the neck and spine with increased pain symptoms, you were correct to
notify your physician and have the physician examine your clinical
situation.
If your physician cannot reassure
you in the diagnosis, you may want to ask for a second opinion with a
neurologist or a physical medicine and rehabilitation doctor. MRI of the
neck or a nerve conduction study may be considered by these specialists to
objectively identify or refute certain causes of your referred pain into
the upper extremity. Hope this helps.
Posted August 7, 2007
Q
Does the labrum attach all the way across the
joint capsule and can you point me in the direction of a good diagram of
the labrum and capsule. Sorry to bother you and thank you for your
assistance.
A
I have expensive human anatomy
books, but I have found that using "google" is very accommodating to
finding medical illustration. If you live near a medical school, you can
visit their library, or even better yet, ask for their anatomy lab where
they may have models or anatomical specimens of the anatomy you wish to
view.
Posted August 7, 2007
Q
Does the knee capsule remain intact
after a total knee arthroplasty?
A
Until recently, a total knee
arthroplasty required a large incision to complete the surgery. Now
smaller incisions are made in certain medical centers with innovative
techniques. Unfortunately, knee surgeries do cut through the capsule, the
question is how much of the capsule depends on the approach and technique.
Posted August 7, 2007
Q
I stumbled across your website while
searching for information about Colles Fractures. I fractured mine ten
weeks ago and it was displaced with ulnar styloid fracture, fixed with
closed reduction and casting. At six weeks the cast was removed and I
was told I probably also had a tear of the Triangular Fibrocartilage
Complex.
I was put in a brace for four more
weeks. So now I am at week ten and beginning physical therapy. The ulnar
side is and always has been very painful, I have a hard time with
supination, and very limited wrist extension. I really feel like my wrist
looks out of place.
The bones just don't look right! It
is also still very painful to supinate and extend with > frequent clicking
sounds from the ulnar side. None of the doctors here seem very concerned
about the pain and limited motion and just keep encouraging me to go to
Physical Therapy. But I know that something isn't right, and feel that my
carpals are not aligned properly as compared to the other side and how it
feels to move my hand! I am concerned that if I don't get appropriate
treatment, it will never heal correctly.
What would you recommend for someone
who lives in a rural area of Alaska with limited resources? And do you
have any suggestions on how I might be able to convince the doctors here
that something isn't right. None of them have performed any sort of
physical exam on my wrist, only looked at the XRAYS and said they look
good. Thanks!
A
Your
description of your injury is almost identical to my son's Adrian's that
led me to find a technique to mobilize the wrist in order to restore range
of motion and eliminate his pain. The only test I could think of is an
MRI of the wrist to describe the extent of the injury.
In regards to manipulation of the
wrist, rural areas have limited resources and specializations. If your
therapist has questions about my technique, the therapist can call my
office and I will try to guide them in their attempt.
Q...
Thank you so much for your reply! After I
have received such minimal responses from my own doctors here, it was
refreshing that you would write back all the way from Florida! I am going
to print out your article on wrist mobilization and I think that the
physical therapist I am seeing here would be interested.
He has most of his background in
Sports Medicine. I am hopeful that he may be the only one here who can
help. I will also give him your website if he needs any more information.
Thank you again for taking the time to write back. I have had many
frustrations here trying to get someone to take me seriously.
The Physical Therapist here did
notice that my carpals do not seem to be aligned properly. I'm not sure
he would know what to do about it, though.
Posted August 2, 2007
Q
I really enjoyed your article on
energy medicine. I am getting trained in energy psychology and
experiencing good results, both in myself and in my patients.
I have a big question.
How detrimental is abdominal surgery
(e.g. a big incision, the removal of an organ like the gall bladder or
uterus, or even the spleen? How does the whole Chinese Medicine system
work when one of its organs is removed. Is the energy flow disrupted
forever or only temporarily?
A
Thanks for your inquiry, but
unfortunately I don't have the knowledge to answer your question, which is
an excellent question.
Posted August 2, 2007
Q
Do you think it would help to
strengthen the brachioradialis to improve the outcome of tennis elbow?
A
Strengthening muscles around the
affected joint and its ligamentous and muscular tendon attachments is
favorable in most situations. However, tennis elbow --epicondylitis has
many different circumstantial mechanisms of injury and inflammatory
healing responses.
Posted July 14, 2007
Q
I was injured in a "Roll-over MVA two years
ago. Cervical and low back pain since. Head trauma with
negative brain scans. I am overweight. I have not been able
to return to work and now I am experiencing leg weakness and falls and
very difficult to ambulate. Much testing and herniations at L-4
through S-1 on MRI with nerve root compression. Any ideas?
A
I have
more questions than answers. Did you see a neurologist, if not you should
be consulting with one. Secondly, did you have a nerve conduction test,
you may need one. Thirdly, did they offer you an epidural corticosteroid
injection to help reduce the size of the disc herniations. Fourth, spinal
decompression may be a conservative measure that could help your
condition. Please respond back, and I will try my best to guide you
through this complex situation.
Posted July 14, 2007
Q
I'm a runner. It doesn't hurt when I run or
jump. However, hurts to laugh or cough and sleeping is tough. Sharp
pain 1 inch above groin on left side and travels down inside of left
leg. Going from lying to standing also tough. I am a 38 year old
female. Could this be a psoas minor strain? It has progressed for 4
months. Has CT of abdomen and pelvis due to pancreatic cyst which is
holding steady. Just had hip x-ray today.
A
The clinical symptoms you present
are more characteristic of the psoas muscle, not so much as the psoas
minor, but most probably of the psoas major muscle. If it is a psoas
major strain, the hip X-ray should be unremarkable.
Posted July 14, 2007
Q
I am a 42 year old woman who enjoys
equestrian riding. I like riding up to four to five times a week.
Unfortunately, I injured myself and have hip pain, tight back, tight
glutes, and loss of flexibility on my right hip. I believe it is
a iliacus strain and psoas problem. I am going to a sports therapist and
his treatment is ultra sound and pressing on the muscle. I don't think
it's helping. I am tighter than before. I have had two treatments.
I have previously seen a doctor and a sports therapist and they did not
diagnose my problem. My range of motion on my right hip is not the same
as my left side. I can feel pain if I press on the Iliacus muscle. I
have had this injury for a year February. Please help! I am in Orange
County, California. Is there any one you can refer me to or help
my sports therapist treat me more effectively.
A
The most likely cause of your
clinical presentation is a shift of the iliacus with the sacral bones, a
sacral-iliac malalignment that osteopathic physicians or chiropractors are
trained to identify and provide manual treatment techniques. The muscles
you describe and the loss of range of motion of the hip is characteristic
of this malalignment.
Posted July 14, 2007
Q
I'm a runner. It doesn't hurt when I run or
jump. However, hurts to laugh or cough and sleeping is tough. Sharp
pain 1 inch above groin on left side and travels down inside of left
leg. Going from lying to standing also tough. I am a 38 year old
female. Could this be a psoas minor strain? It has progressed for 4
months. Has CT of abdomen and pelvis due to pancreatic cyst which is
holding steady. Just had hip x-ray today.
A
The clinical symptoms you present
are more characteristic of the psoas muscle, not so much as the psoas
minor, but most probably of the psoas major muscle. If it is a psoas
major strain, the hip X-ray should be unremarkable.
Q...
I have a follow up question please. I saw my
regular Dr. today, I see an Ortho. next week, however, there was a marked
decrease in muscle strength in my left leg, I'd lift it, and she could
push it right down, kind of embarrassing for me. Is that normal with a
muscle strain of the psoas, are there any nerves that run through there,
any thoughts you have on this would be helpful until I can get to see the
Ortho.
A...Medically,
the most common weakness of specific muscle is a neurologic impairment of
the innervation or supplying nerve to that muscle. However, if the
movement of that specific muscle against resistance creates a painful
condition, the muscle may simulate a "functional" weakness. To properly
determine which is the case relies on the clinician who is examining you
and they can make the clinical decision on how to proceed in diagnostic
testing. They may refer you to a neurologist to make the definitive
determination and clinical impression.
Posted July 9, 2007
Q
I am doing a paper for a coaching
class and have a few questions before I get started. My paper is on
Golf and Class 3 Lever.
My
questions:
1) In golf, where would the effort be in a lever.
2) Can resistance arm and effort arm be changed?
3) If so, how does that affect movement?
4) Where does the "effort" come from on the golf club?
I
sincerely appreciate any information you can offer. Thank you for your
time.
A
Your questions are excellent
physics questions. I would refer you to the best source, David
Tuttleman a former NASA aerospace engineer who has written and studied
the physics of golf. If you "google" his name, he has a telephone
number to his home or web site and he can best answer your technical
questions. Hope this helps.
Posted July 9, 2007
Q
My son is a 15 year old high school
baseball pitcher. He did not pitch for two month because his arm bones
were growing faster than his muscles. He was put into a program of
exercises to strengthen the bones which are fine now. In the
course of the therapy they made a correction to his pitching mechanics
so as to reduce the chance of injury. He started to throw the ball
and pain came to the front of his shoulder which was diagnose as a new
muscle being used as a direct result of the new mechanics. What exercise
or throwing program you recommend to strengthen that particular muscle.
The arrow shows were it hurts.

A
The arrow points to a most
critical point in the shoulder complex, the area of the acromial-clavicle
junction, the area of the anterior labrum. The pain may be a strain on
the shoulder and with the amount of force in the pitching motion, he may
be at risk of tearing his labrum, the rim of the shoulder capsule. Before
I would instruct him to work through this pain, have him see an
osteopathic physician or a chiropractor to align the acromial-clavicular
joint with the clavicle. This will align the muscles anatomically and
reduce the torque on the anterior shoulder. This is the first step and
the most important in resolving his pain condition.
Posted July 9, 2007
Q
I was reading your website and the
information that was presented was great. My situation involved what I
believe to be a "fight or flight" syndrome. I had just given a
presentation in class, when back to sit down and felt a nervous shake in
my neck. The next day, I woke up with an incredibly sore neck and upper
back. I initially attributed my "fight or flight" response to excessive
caffeine use and stress from school, but after further analysis believe
excessive physical exertion at the gym as a likely cause. My trapezius
muscles always feel tight, and strained.
A
The trapezius strain across the
tops of the shoulders is more commonly caused from a strain in the lower
cervical--upper thoracic vertebral area. I would start with consulting an
osteopathic physician or chiropractor and have a spinal adjustment
attempted. Let me know how you progress.
Posted July 8, 2007
Q
I have had severe neck pain for six
months now. I have had pain on the right side of my neck extending to
the back of my neck on the right side. I have tried everything from
physical therapy, chiropractic, neurologist, and my regular doctor. I
missed three weeks of work in March because of an exercise I did from
physical therapy. I was doing the neck glide exercise and that caused me
to have a constant pain in the right occipital area. The neurologist put
me on neurontin for the pain but it has helped only slightly. I do
exercise and try to do neck exercises as much as possible but the neck
glide causes the most pain. Could you please tell me what that neck
glide exercise might be doing to me? I have an appointment with my
neurologist at the end of July.
A
Reading your symptoms, you may
have a strain of the suboccipital muscle called the splenius capitis. Use
google to find the anatomical position and more importantly the referred
pain patterns. This is a very difficult muscle to treat effectively. Let
me know if this "fits" with your clinical picture.
Posted June 20, 2007
Q
I am a very fit, athletic 65 year old woman,
5'7", 122 lbs.. I took up golf two years ago and am passionate about
it. My Index is 118. Last January, I adopted a more athletic stance
to gain more distance. I believe this is the cause for the strain I
am experiencing on the piriformis muscle in the lead (left) hip. The
first incident was quite painful (no instant pain, but grew while
warming up at the driving range).
At first, I thought it was the
labrum. We were in Hawaii and I was researching it on the web. 21/2
weeks later, I was playing golf. This latest occurrence is not as severe,
but non the less, keeping me from golf and walking fast. I can go up
stairs, but not down. I can easily flutter kick my legs on my stomach -
as well as lifting them. I saw a PT today and had stem and ice. We did
some stretches that I have already been doing. It did not help. Am on
antiflammatory. Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated.
A
The symptoms you describe fit the
diagnosis of a sacral-iliac syndrome. This is a very common problem and
most often managed effectively by a competent chiropractor or osteopathic
physician. The sacral-iliac shift changes the alignment of the hamstrings
and quadriceps muscles and leads to strains of these muscle groups.
Pain is experienced with sitting
over the sacral notch. The piriformis and gluteal muscles are also
affected. If the piriformis if moderately severely strained, this may
result in the irritation of the sciatic nerve and lead to sciatica. To
review, start with chiropractic or osteopathic physicians.
Posted June 20, 2007
Q
I had my knee scoped 8 weeks
ago and I can do light workouts but I still am having pain in running.
Is this normal? Do i have anymore options as to rehabilitation?
A
Arthroscopic surgery serves two
purposes, one is diagnostic, and the second to "clean up" the joint
space. To help you with your problem, I would need to know the symptoms,
your age, the diagnosis and why the surgery was performed. I also need to
know if the same symptoms persist or are these new symptoms?
Posted June 20, 2007
Q
I have spondylolisthesis grade one with
stenosis, degenerative disc. The pain has gotten worse the last 6
months. I am 61 years old and have had two surgeons tell me that I
need surgery with fusion. I am trying to avoid that and have gone to
different chiropractors. I just quit one chiropractor after 17
treatments because I felt worse. I would like to try Decompression
therapy and was wondering if this would be a better move
before surgery.
I have had 3 epidural injections and only got
relief for about 2 weeks each.
Do you know of a good doctor in the Columbus Ohio
area that does decompression therapy?
I also have been reading about decompression and
there are so many different models - recently read about the SpineMed.
What do you suggest?
Very tired of hurting. I love to walk about 30
minutes in the evenings and I am having a rough time now. I get
terrible muscle spasms about 20 minutes into my walking.
Any help will be very much appreciated.
A
Grade one spondylolisthesis rarely
requires surgery. Chiropractors usually aggravate it and as you found
cortisone is only a temporary help. Decompression therapy may be of help
as inversion tables. You can inquire on google or call some larger rehab
centers and ask if they own a unit, if not if they know which facility
owns one as you have a "prescription" for such a service. Let me know how
you respond.
Posted June 20, 2007
Q
I am having a problem with my
left hip. This injury occurred while swinging a 7 iron. I am right
handed thus when I made my swing and turn to hit the golf ball I hit
the ground and instantly I had pain in my left hip. The pain is in the
area were the thigh meets the pelvis. I applied ice as soon as I
completed golf and I continued for several days.
Immediately after the injury I was
not able to make a complete golf swing without have serve pain after I
rotated the hip. I cannot put any weight on my left side. When I walk up
stairs and place my left foot onto the step I immediately will feel
severe pain in my left hip. Did I injury or strain a muscle? What should
I do to rehabilitate my injury? Can you recommend MD in the Fort Myers,
Fl area?
A
You have an interesting
presentation of turning on lead hip and creating a painful hip with
weightbearing. I think that the problem is a sprain of tendon or ligament
that attaches to the hip bone, the head of the femur. I don't know anyone
in Fort Myers, but I have a practice in Bradenton, and would be pleased to
evaluate your clinical problem.
Posted June 20, 2007
Q
My symptoms are knee pain
below and behind the right knee. I just turned 31. The surgery was
preformed because of a 20 to 30% tear of the petal tendon. The injury
occurred when training for a tryout. The pain is not as bad but still
there. I can do most everything I used to just without the weight. It
has been more that 2 months since the surgery.
A
The pain from a torn patellar
tendon would be at the knee cap and below located in the front of the
leg. The pain behind the knee could be one of many structures including
but not limited to the posterior cruciate ligament, the posterior meniscus
(cartilage), the attachment of the hamstring muscles, a posterior ligament
or small popliteus muscle. If you find a large "sack" of fluid, this is
called a Baker's cyst. A Baker's cyst is a benign condition, but large
sacks that interfere with knee bending may require surgical removal. Hope
this helps you.
Posted June 20, 2007
Q
In the study with over and
underweighted balls, what was the
routine. How many times was each ball
thrown and how many days a week?
A
The information you inquired
about can be found in the original research paper published in the
Journal of Applied Sports Science Research, 1990, Volume 4, Number 1,
pp. 16-19. This was a study done at the Univ. of Hawaii HPER Department
with the lead researcher being Coop DeRenne. Other articles from this
group were accepted to the National Strength and Conditioning
Association handbooks and resources. If you can't find the articles,
write me back.
Posted June 20, 2007
Q
In your online
article entitled Muscle Memory and Motor Learning In Golf you
refer to research done at the University of Chicago "studying
professional golfers and muscle memory". I would like to find out a
great deal more about this research. Do you have a reference for this
work? Has any of this work been published? Any help you could give me
in finding out more about this work would be greatly appreciated.
A
The University of Chicago study
was done in the 1990's and I don't have the paper readily available. An
extension of the study was done at the Univ. of Calgary with the article
published as "Quiet Eye" phenomenon. But to answer your question, I don't
have the article in my possession. The article could be found on "google"
with typing words of EEG, golf, Univ of Chicago, ect. Hope you find it.
I will look for it also to complete my reference papers.
Posted May 21, 2007
Q
I'm having a problem with my downswing
sequence squaring the clubface is a chore. I also pull the ball
frequently. I turn back with my shoulders ,then after that I am lost.
Any help would be appreciated.
A
Unfortunately, I am not a
qualified professional golf instructor. There are too many variables to
review on what would cause flaws in your golf swing. Consider finding a
reputable pro who could advise you on your flaw and make beneficial
corrections. Sorry that I couldn't be of more help.
Posted May 21, 2007
Q
I am experiencing extreme pain in my lower
back, buttock, pain radiating down my right thigh, muscle spasm and
calf pain. I have numbness and tingling in my big toe, as well as
the sole of my right foot. So far anti-inflammatory, Tylenol 3 and
neurontin seem to have no affect.
I am trying every morning to do a
regime of stretching as well and also am using heat, My hip also is very
painful and walking, rising from bed is difficult. I have already
experienced back surgery many years ago (a laminectomy) the left side was
the problem.
I am also experiencing pain in my
neck, right arm pain, tingling in my fingers, wrist pain as well as
shoulder pain and nerve pain down my right arm. My entire right side seems
to be a huge problem. When I see my doctor, he attributes all
symptoms to Fibromyalgia. Can you help?
A
I have seen fibromyalgia present
with this type of presentation. However, to assure yourself that no
diagnosis is missed, you should consult with a neurologist to give you a
thorough exam and possibly more testing. If you live near a medical
school teaching hospital, that would be preferable to seek a consultation
there rather than a solo practicing physician.
Posted May 18, 2007
Q
I'm just needing some further advice on an
injury I sustained last year in hope to return to competitive boxing and
kickboxing.
Last August I had an accident which caused a
compression fracture to L2 & L3. Luckily there was no nerve or
disc damage involved so I have managed to recover quite fast.
I started Physical Therapy 1 month after the
injury followed by seeing a Osteopath and having one-on-one pilates
classes over a two month period.
I am a very active person who loves running,
pilates, kayaking, boxing & kickboxing. As yet I have only been able to
partake in pilates classes and have gradually built up from power
walking to being able to run again (only for around 30mins per session
at the moment on grass, not concrete at my Dr suggested)
I am craving to start boxing and kickboxing again
but am lost as to how I should be training without hurting myself. 3
months ago I went to my boxing gym and as a result of 1 hour boxing
training I put my back out for 2 weeks so I'm scared that this will
happen again.
Is there any advice you can please give me to help
me get back on my feet again?
A
Thank you for your inquiry. You
are the active type. Not sure if you are participating in contact or
non-contact boxing. Non contact boxing may be easier on your back than
non-contact kickboxing. As you have had a compression fracture in the
higher lumbar spine, your lateral spine flexor the muscle called the
quadratus lumborum will be actively contracted.
The compression fractures do
change the spinal heights and predispose to smaller muscle and
intervertebral ligament increased tensions and more vunerable to strain
and sprain. Your osteopath should diagnose the reason for your spinal
spasm and identify what types of movements would predispose to
recurrence.
Your question of whether this
injury can recur, the answer is a strong probability. However, recurrent
strains should not be immediately associated with harm or permanency in
injury. You may also want to consider an effective pre-activity
stretching program along with a soft flexible abdominal-low back binder as
support during your athletic activity. I hope I have answered your
questions.
Q...Thanks
for your prompt response to my query.
Given that the injury occurred 9 Months ago, how
long do you think I should give before I begin contact boxing classes?
At my boxing gym they have both boxing cardio (on punching bags) and
boxing technique (one on one with a partner) classes.
That is my last question!! I promise!
A....My
response, why would you want to return to contact boxing, and risk other
injuries. You already have compression fractures of the spine. Yes
they heal, but they are never the same structure and prone to more micro
fractures. In this case, I would ask you orthopedic surgeon for advice,
but my advice is not to return to contact boxing. Sorry, probably not
the answer you were seeking.
Posted May 10, 2007
Q
My 14 year old son was hit by a pitch last
night. He was struck on the ulna. We took him to Kaiser and an x-ray of
the possible fracture site was taken. The x-ray was reviewed by a
Physician's assistant who said that there was a "questionable" fracture
right below the growth plate. When we went to the cast room, the
attendant there said he didn't see a fracture. I have requested the
x-rays and will be pursuing an outside opinion. My son is also a runner
and is scheduled to run in a meet on Saturday (three days from today).
He is a very good runner and stands
to win both of his events (mile and 800). He is in a fiberglass cast and
wants to run. If this "fracture" is indeed questionable, wouldn't it make
sense to first of all, have a radiologist review the films, and secondly,
to put him in a splint rather than a cast? I'm tempted to remove the cast
if I can't get the x-rays reviewed prior to the meet. What is the worst
case scenario if he runs with a "questionable" transverse fracture?
A
Quick answer, if he runs with no
cast or splint and should fall, he would shift the fractured bone and
require probable surgery and this would change the muscle lengths in his
growth and take away from his potential in throwing. Get an opinion from
an orthopedist, but do not jeopardize the fracture from getting worse.
Posted May 10, 2007
Q
I've had a problem with my left wrist as long
as I can remember. I have only about 30% mobility when it comes to
rotating it (I don't know the technical term for this motion). This has
given me problems when I've tried to play lacrosse, and made playing the
guitar almost impossible for me. I even tried playing left-handed (I'm
right-handed) but ran into problems with my left hand trying to strum.
I saw a doctor 8 years ago who told me that it looked like one of the
ligaments connecting my radius and ulna were too tight. They could
stretch it out, but they wouldn't know how much to stretch it.
Also, when I do rotate my wrist if I flex it downwards towards my arm, a
small soft-ish lump protrudes, I have no idea what it is.
I really want this problem fixed, do you have any guidance?
A
First, the small lump over the
wrist area. It is most likely a cyst, called a ganglion and is benign.
If it interferes with motion or causes pain, surgery needs to be done to
excise the entire cyst and permanently remove it. With movement and
friction, this cyst can grow in size. Stabilizing the wrist or limiting
use may shrink this ganglion cyst.
The other possibility is the
lunate bone. Divers push this small bone, the lunate outwards from the
back of the hand/wrist area and frequently tape it down during training.
I would doubt the scenario of the ligaments being too tight and would get
other surgical opinions before anyone operated on my wrists for tight
ligaments. Do you remember having any injury or trauma to the wrist in
the past?
Posted May 10, 2007
Q
Six
years ago, I was involved in a car accident. I was hit from behind and
pushed into the car in front of me. I had severe pain in my hip and leg
immediately. This went away a few days later, but three days later I
could not move my neck at all. I had no range of motion to the left side
pain in my shoulder, and down into the top part of my arm.
I was first diagnosed with cervical whiplash with distonia. I have gone
through pt for six months, pain management one year. including
medications, trigger point injections cervical blocks
Botox to no avail. I
have extension forward but no backward movement of my neck. I have severe
headaches under the occipital lobe which goes up the back of my head and
into my eyes and into the left side of my face as well. This is severe
pain. I never have a second that I am not in pain from this now.
The
pain is starting to continue down my arm below my elbow and into my hand.
They easily go numb and there is sharp pain in my thumb and first finger
also. Six years later my diagnosis is chronic myofascial pain
syndrome including referred pain. How can whiplash turn into a lifelong
disability such as this. Should I have something that has not been done
tried at this time or is this it. The pain doctor I had seen also said I
did everything he would have tried.
A
First of all, I would suggest
cervical flexion and extension X-rays. Then I would suggest finding a
competent osteopathic or chiropractic physician to manually adjust your
cervical spine. You may have malalignments of the upper cervical
vertebrae at C2 which cause headaches and attach to the scalene muscles.
I don't think you have had much experience with manual techniques to
realign your spinal segments.
Posted May 10, 2007
Q
I have a son who is the top 9
yr old golfer in the area. He loves to play soccer as well but golf is
his love. Lately he been wanting to play baseball. The question is, will
playing baseball and being taught how to hit a baseball slow down, have
and effect or hurt his golf swing?
A
This is a great question. The old
school taught not to cross over in sports. However, biomechanics found
that golf and baseball hold many similarities in swing motions. Eye hand
coordination is different. I think that playing different sports can have
similar movements is not a factor in so as much as him trying
weightlifting which would increase bulk and interfere with his flexibility
and agility. Finally, I have not seen any studies that studied crossover
sports training.
Posted May 9, 2007
Q How would you correct a
psoas weakness bilaterally using kinesiology?
A
I don't have any one specific
exercise a psoas as it is a deep muscle that acts as a hip flexor and
rotator. How do you recognize that it is weak and differentiate it from
the iliacus group? If you paraphrase what other muscle groups you are
interested in strengthening or what condition, maybe I could be more of a
resource.
Posted May 9, 2007
Q
I have an injury that has not gone away in 2
months. It is Kind of an ab strain (feels tight when i stretch all the way
up) and kind of a groin strain (it only hurts when i adduct my leg
standing and dragging the foot against the ground, and only in the Range
of motion closer to the centerline) It also hurts when i drag it against
the ground (leg straight again) in a roller blading t-stop kind of
position.
I can squat ok, but the exercise that hurts is a HIGH box step up (mid
thigh). I have been training around it with high box sq, and pulls.
The pain is only on one side (right) and exactly next to the ahem... pee
pee. What are suggestions or experiences?
A
Based on your history, you should
see a physician to make sure you don't have an inguinal hernia or
testicular torsion. These are the two most common presentations are you
clinically describe in your question. The other possibility may be a
sacral malalignment or subluxation. For this sacral-pelvic malalignment
you may want to consult and osteopathic or chiropractic physician. Hope
this helps.
Posted April 26, 2007
Q
I am a physiotherapist. I am
informally trying to get some information regarding prognosis for
patients with a Grade 4 Spondylolisthesis. The Grade 4 is a symptomatic
Grade 4, progressed from a Grade 2-3 (asymptomatic) prior to the fall.
If you have any comments regarding
this I would appreciate them.
A
A grade IV Spondylolisthesis is
very unstable and may require surgical rodding and fusion. It is unlikely
you would change the clinical situation and may even make it worse. I
would seek a neurosurgical opinion.
Posted April 26, 2007
Q
Having read your article
re. Golfer’s back problems, I am having these conditions just now. I have
seen my doctor, and he has given me pain killers and some physiotherapy,
however after some 6 weeks I am still unable to carry out a golf swing
without considerable pain above and to the back of my right hip. Have you
any suggestions as to what I can do to improve my condition.
A
Based on the information you
provide, I think you have a slight malalignment of the sacral-iliac which
causes increase strain of the low back muscles, the quadratus lumborum and
the buttock muscles, gluteus medius and minimus muscles. Additional
problems of this malalignment result in quadriceps and hamstring
tightness. A consultation with an osteopathic physician or a competent
chiropractor is probably your best choice.
Posted April 23, 2007
Q
Can you identify physiatrists
in my area?
A
To find a physiatrist in your
area, you may contact the American Academy of Physical Medicine and
Rehabilitation either on the web site or their main office in Chicago,
IL. Additionally, each physiatrist may have their own area of expertise.
Posted April 23, 2007
Q
What is a safe age to start
throwing a curve ball and what are the dangers?
A
I would refer you to the expert Dr. Mike Marshall,
former Cy Young pitcher and PhD in kinesiology. He has a web site devoted
to pitching and answers all emails at his web page
www.drmikemarshall.com
Posted April 23, 2007
Q
I
fractured my right wrist Nov 1, 2006. |